Should we recruit a generalist or a specialist?
Start with the problems that need attention. A smaller team may need a broad HR practitioner, while a recurring employee relations, systems or learning challenge may need deeper experience in that area. List the decisions and outputs rather than relying on the title alone.
Can they manage a performance improvement process?
They can help a manager prepare evidence, hold an appropriate discussion and follow up agreed support. Fair Work guidance describes a process that includes the employee’s response and review of progress. Your authorised manager retains the employment decisions, with specialist advice where needed. Fair Work Underperformance Guidance
Can AI make HR decisions for the team?
Do not treat an AI output as an employment decision or an established fact about a person. OAIC guidance highlights privacy risks when using commercial AI with personal information. Define approved uses, review outputs and keep confidential workforce information out of unapproved tools. OAIC Commercial AI Privacy Guidance
Can they write our policies?
They can draft and improve policies within their experience, but the relevant owner must review scope, legal requirements and operational implications. A useful policy should tell people what to do and who decides exceptions. Copying another organisation’s rules rarely resolves those questions.
How should we measure the role’s contribution?
Use the outputs relevant to the brief: clearer manager guidance, better case records, completed follow-up actions or fewer repeated process errors. Review the quality and fairness of the process alongside timeliness. Closing cases quickly is not useful if issues remain unresolved or records omit important facts.